Posts mit dem Label stealth werden angezeigt. Alle Posts anzeigen
Posts mit dem Label stealth werden angezeigt. Alle Posts anzeigen

Mittwoch, 15. September 2021

Ein frühes Meisterwerk des Stealth-Genres. Thief: The Dark Project (1998)

 


Es ist Nacht. Meisterdieb Garrett steht zu später Stunde in Farkus‘ Laden. Farkus ist einer der wenigen Händler, die nach der Sperrstunde noch eine offene Tür für zwielichtige Gestalten wie Garrett haben. Doch seit einer ganzen Weile stehen da zwei Kerle vor der Tür, die selbst ihm unbekannt sind. Mit einem Male wird Farkus von einem Pfeil getroffen – er ist sofort tot. Es bleiben Garrett wenige Sekunden, zu realisieren, dass es offenbar eine Verwechslung gegeben hat – der tödliche Pfeil hatte eigentlich ihm selbst gegolten. Jetzt heißt es: Schleunigst die Beute einsacken und hinterher. Typen wie diese kann Garrett nicht gebrauchen, denn sobald sie ihren Irrtum bemerken, werden sie erneut zuschlagen – so viel ist sicher. 


Gealtert wie feiner Wein

Thief: The Dark Project ist jetzt 23 Jahre alt, und dennoch spielenswert – ja, ich behaupte dreist, dass es stimmiger ist als beispielsweise das wunderschöne Shadow of the Tomb Raider (2018) oder die moderne Hitman-Reihe (2016-2021) – immerhin zwei renommierte Stealth-Kollegen.

Manch einer wird jetzt einwenden: Woran liegt das, und warum lautet die Antwort ‚Nostalgie‘? Dem erwidere ich: Falsch! Oder: Nur teilweise richtig. Denn offensichtliche Schwachstellen wie die etwas hölzerne grafische Aufmachung weiß Thief gekonnt auszubügeln mit einer dichten Atmosphäre, die noch heute dem Spieler tatsächlich das Gefühl gibt, ein listiger Dieb in einer lebendigen Welt zu sein.

 

Mit dem Blackjack kann man die Wache schnell ins Reich der Träume schicken.

Thief spielt in einer namenlosen Stadt, in der nichts so ist, wie es auf den ersten Blick scheint. Die erste Mission versetzt den Spieler in ein prunkvoll ausgestattetes Schloss mit Teppichen, Galerien und Bibliotheken. Die Wachen sind entweder betrunken oder meckern über ihren knurrenden Magen und der Spieler erkennt: Offenbar bin ich hier in einem finsteren, aber nicht humorlosen Mittelalter gelandet.

Später kommen fantastische Kreaturen wie dicke, feuerspeiende Echsen (Burricks) und Zombies hinzu, aber gleichzeitig schleicht sich immer auch ein bisschen Steampunk hinein: Primitive Aufzüge und elektrische Alarmsysteme sind fest verbaut in den massiven Burgen und Kirchen, die das Stadtbild prägen. Genaugenommen betreibt Thief gar eine Subversion des Steampunk, indem es auf allzu müde Klischees wie Zylinder und Monokel verzichtet und seine ächzenden Dampfmaschinen und magischen Straßenlaternen gekonnt mit mittelalterlicher Ästhetik verzahnt. Knarzende Türen, rotierende Maschinen und das Pfeifen einer patrouillierenden Wache füllen die Welt mit Leben, und ein Hauch Film Noir liegt in der Luft.

Religiöse Ikonografie und massive Zahnräder stellen in dieser Welt keinen ästhetischen Widerspruch dar.
 
Die Cutscenes versprühen Film-Noir-Flair.

Ein bisschen Schaudern ist erlaubt

Doch nicht nur die Lebenden machen sich lautstark bemerkbar, auch die Toten sind rastlos. In einer späteren Mission muss der vom Spieler gesteuerte Meisterdieb in eine verfluchte Kathedrale einbrechen. Mit primitiven Blendgranaten („Blitzbomben“) und Weihwasser ausgestattet, stellt er sich untoten Geistlichen, die ihm entweder als kettenrasselnde, aber blitzschnelle, in leuchtendes Rot gekleidete Schädelfratzen begegnen oder als untote Priester, die, unablässig in einer unergründlichen Sprache fluchend, Garrett mit magischen Totenschädeln beschießen. 

Die verfluchte Kathedrale.

Ein geübter Dieb jedoch kann all diesem Ärger entgehen, indem er sich vorsichtig und methodisch durch das entweihte Gotteshaus bewegt und jeden Zentimeter Schatten mit geübtem Auge zu vermessen weiß. Ein Lichtjuwel am unteren Rand des Bildschirms gibt Feedback, wie sichtbar die Spielfigur für ihre Feinde ist. Allerdings ist Garrett auch ein Freund harter Absatzschuhe. So veranstaltet der Meisterdieb ziemlichen Lärm auf marmornen Fliesen, wenn er zu hastig ist – Vorsicht ist geboten.

Die licht- und geräuschempfindliche künstliche Intelligenz ist dabei weiter, als man es für ein Spiel aus dem Jahre 1998 vermuten würde, wenngleich auch sie nicht ganz frei von Bugs ist. Mit seinem neuartigen Stealth-Gameplay läutete Thief (neben wenigen anderen Spielen) einen epochalen Umbruch für das First-Person-Spiel ein, das in der breiten Öffentlichkeit allerdings noch jahrelang in erster Linie mit sog. Killerspielen à la Doom oder Castle Wolfenstein assoziiert werden sollte. Inzwischen aber lösen Egoshooter keine Gewaltdebatten mehr aus, sondern bedienen sich eigener Stealth-Mechaniken – ein Vermächtnis auch der Thief-Reihe.

 

Ein unvorsichtiger Dieb endet schnell als Zombie-Piñata.

In der Kathedrale angekommen, lasse ich Garrett behutsam die Emporen erklimmen – denn der primitive Aufzug ist defekt. Seilpfeile oder gezielte Sprünge schaffen Abhilfe. Die Atmosphäre ist intensiv wie in einem Resident Evil, aber die historische Dimension ist gewaltiger, hier spukt der Geist der Knechtschaft, Folter und Hexenverfolgung. Diese Welt wird nicht von strahlenden Paladinen beherrscht, sondern vom ewigen Widerstreit zwischen dem religiösen Orden der handwerklich begabten Hammeriten und den mysteriösen, im Wald beheimateten Heiden. 

 

Der ewige Widerstreit zwischen dem Waldfürsten und dem Erbauer um die Gunst der Menschheit ist der Stoff von Legenden.
 

Garrett findet sich unverhofft zwischen den Fronten wieder, wie sich schon bald herausstellen soll. Doch zunächst berge ich einen magischen Edelstein, der sogleich zu mir spricht: Wozu die Eile? So einfach lässt mich das eigensinnige Juwel nicht gehen. Kraft seiner magischen Aura hat es die Vordertür versiegelt. 

Der ruhelose Bruder Murus fungiert als Questgeber.

Auf der Suche nach einem alternativen Ausgang stoße ich erstmals auf eine friedfertige Seele an diesem verfluchten Ort. Der Geist von Bruder Murus bittet mich, ihn von den Qualen des Untodes zu befreien. Es folgen ein paar fetch-quests, an deren buchstäblichem Höhepunkt ich das Observatorium betrete, wo die jetzt rastlosen Toten einst, zu ihren Lebzeiten, den Lauf der Sterne studierten. Hier befindet sich ein Becken, in dessen klarem Wasser letzte Spuren göttlichen Lichtes zu finden sind: Das reicht, um ein heiliges Symbol zu weihen, welches für eine rituelle Beerdigung benötigt wird. Als seine Seele endlich frei ist, lässt mir Bruder Murus einen Schlüssel zum Dachboden da, wo ich allerlei nützliche Ausrüstung finde. Schließlich gelingt es mir – sehr indiskret für einen Meisterdieb – das massive Tor der Klostermauer zu sprengen. Endlich frei!

Der Spieler ist der Souverän

Während der Mission habe ich die volle Kontrolle über Garrett. Keine Cutscenes unterbrechen das Geschehen – kurze, hervorragend synchronisierte Videos gibt es erst nach dem Level. Es blitzen auch keine Steam-Errungenschaften auf, die mir versichern würden, dass ich gerade alles richtig mache. Die Schauplätze, die Geschichte darin und darum sind interessant genug und erklären sich von allein: Wer sich unbeschadet durchschlagen will, muss sich vollkommen auf diese Welt einlassen. Mit einer gewissen Selbstverständlichkeit bekommt der Spieler sein Werkzeug an die Hand gegeben: Hier sind Wasserpfeile – sie löschen Fackeln und schaffen so dunkle Ecken zum Zurückziehen. Moospfeile erzeugen einen Untergrund, der die Geräusche deiner Schritte dämpft. Hier ist dein Schwert, mit dem du kämpfen kannst, wenn es brenzlig wird. Hier ist eine Karte – sie mag nicht sonderlich detailliert sein, vielleicht ist sie gar veraltet – aber du bist klug genug, die Lücken selbst zu füllen.

Und darin liegt für mich die große Stärke von Thief. Das Spiel erklärt sich nur so weit, wie es muss und ist elegant in seinem Minimalismus. Gleichzeitig gibt es viel zu entdecken und meine schnell wachsenden Fähigkeiten erlauben es mir, verschiedene Routen und Spielweisen auszuprobieren, um an die kostbaren Schätze dieser ungewöhnlichen Welt zu gelangen.

 

Der exzentrische Constantine wird zu einem wichtigen Kontakt für Garrett.

Thief: The Dark Project ist derzeit in Form der Gold-Version für einen schmalen Taler zu haben – die gog-Version ist sogar bereits für moderne Systeme gepatched. Die Gold-Version bietet drei zusätzliche Level, die aber nur etwas für echte Liebhaber sind: Die Level sind schlicht ein bisschen zu groß geraten und erfordern sehr viel Umherrennen. Mein Tipp: Die Levels so lange spielen, bis sie anfangen, zu nerven und dabei so viel Gold wie möglich für die nächste Mission einsammeln. Dann: STRG+ALT+SHIFT+END. You’re welcome. Am besten noch ist Song in the Caverns gelungen, ein spannender Zweiteiler mit einigen Überraschungen und atmosphärisch bereits sehr dicht am zweiten Teil dank neuer visueller assets.

Die Magiertürme ist eine konzeptionell interessante Mission, aber zu lang.

Abschließend bleibt zu sagen: Thief besticht nach wie vor durch seine exzellente Soundkulisse, seine packende Mittelalter-Atmosphäre und sein schlankes, aber in die Tiefe reichendes Gameplay. Selten hat ein Spiel ein derart gelungenes Gesamtpaket aus Spielspaß, Spannung und originellen Ideen geliefert.


Mittwoch, 14. September 2016

Thief II: The Metal Age – All should hear the words of Karras!


He who keeps his work in disorder
gives home to chaos.

Let him be struck
with stone and iron
to forge away
his flaws.

[Excerpt from Karras' Sermons]

Thief II: The Metal Age, released in 2000, is the successor of Looking Glass’ Thief: The Dark Project and after all these years still possibly the best stealth game of all time. It stays true to its remarkable predecessor and improved on just about everything.
 
It is night. You feel a chilly breeze, but it may become the wind of change. The formerly dark street glows in cold, metallic light. There are no trees, but cold, hard sculptures of masked angels and cogs mark the way of the Master Builder. Premodern urban sprawl encompasses all that used to be rural streets inhabited by wildlife. Metal beams and marble tiles have replaced the wooden structures and carved stone of old.

One year has passed since Garrett stole the Eye for Constantine, who turned out to be the incarnation of the Trickster, a deity of nature and chaos. Upon realizing his mistake, Garrett barely managed to escape with his skin, only to infiltrate the Trickster's lair for one last time more in order to banish him from the mortal realm with the help of a strategically deployed booby trap - sponsored by the tech-loving Order of the Hammer.

"If thou art my enemy, fear thou my power, for it is granted me by Karras
that I may smite all within the scope of mine eye."

The moral of the story is: Listen to the keepers (= the city's secret guardians). If they hide said indestructible Eye, described it as a “great, ancient evil”, you’d better leave it alone. 
 
However, the next threat is just around the corner: It's the dawn of the Metal Age. As the Trickster's magic fades away, the former Hammerite priest and self-proclaimed prophet Karras sets out to overthrow the world in the name of science, steampunk technology and religious extremism.

The developers at Looking Glass Studios knew exactly where they wanted to go with Thief II: More sneaking, less thrashing. So instead of shoving Burricks in your face, they opted for stealth and added a few nice gimmicks. Garrett, who lost his eye during the events of the first game, now has a mechanical substitute which he can throw around corners to catch a glimpse from a safe distance. This useful tool soon becomes a necessity as the newly industrialized world itself is under the scrutiny of eyes, both living and dead: Not only are there guards on patrol, but fully automated security cameras. If you stay in their field of vision for too long, they will glow with red light and alert guards to your presence.

If the security cam has spotted you (top center), the turret (left)
will fire bombs at you and the guards won't give a warming welcome either.

However, in many cases, these can be turned off by a switch which sometimes is, most conveniently, nearby the camera, but other times you will have to search a little or cannot switch them off at all. In later levels, there will even be turrets connected to the camera - no need for backup.
 
But these are not the biggest threats. One of the most interesting and controversial implementations are the robots. There are small worker bots which pose as much of a threat as an irritated servant, but there are also combat bots which will, upon being alerted, shoot a grenade at you with great precision and velocity. If you manage to sneak behind them, you can shoot water arrows into their boiler – 2 will disable them permanently. But facing them directly will be a challenge you’d rather avoid, trust me.

Nevertheless, I love them. You will hear them approach from afar as they stomp down an alleyway, playing recordings of Karras sermons, read by the man himself: The flesh is imperfect, it is unclean, it putrefies, but I am forged in The Builder's image: without... flesh. They are absolutely uncanny and terrifying. Awesome. 

Just a little worker bot, strolling through the First City Bank and Trust.

But of course, there are plenty of human guards around still. After all, Thief wouldn’t be Thief without them mumbling to themselves or gossiping around, and in this installment there are some hilarious scenes. In my favourite level, Blackmail, Garrett breaks into Sherriff Truart’s estate to confront him with an incriminating recording, but before events get serious, the player has a chance to listen to a guard named Benny complaining to the barista about some spilled mead. It turns out that Benny, the old drunkard, was the one who spilled it in the first place, which is made all the more hilarious thanks to Steven Russell’s brilliant voice acting skills (he voices Garrett and Karras, too!). Later, in Life of the Party, you may enjoy a quarrel between guards turning into a full-blown fight.

Speaking of which, Life of the Party definitely deserves mentioning as well. It is an absolutely huge level, but it is full of secrets, occurrences and strange things; even the keepers pay a visit – twice. What makes this level stand out is the setting, as the player has to travel across the rooftops of the city (instead of walking through the streets) to infiltrate Karras’ bureau in a gigantic tower. Levels like this are a huge improvement over the extra Gold levels of Thief I, which mostly felt empty and monotonous. On a less positive note, Thief II levels feature so much urban space that the few undead inhabitants often feel crammed in a tiny space, where they patrol endlessly around the same four corners (most notably in Eavesdropping). Undead have become more of a bonus and less of a feature.The truly horrible revelations are in-between rather than in obvious locations, which might be a bit of a disappointment for fans of levels like Return to the Haunted Cathedral.

A crazy leader...

There are many minor changes in gameplay, too. Thief II is, as mentioned, a lot more consequent when it comes to stealth, but that does not mean that the difficulty level is too high. The levels are easier to navigate now, because the developers have abandoned the rather monotonous, maze-like style of some earlier levels. Also, all food now restores a low amount of health, which is a nice gimmick and sometimes very helpful. Garrett finally got himself a flashlight (“flare”), which is needed especially in some versions of the game where you cannot adjust the brightness (fail!), and you can now freely bind the key for quicksave, which makes playing the game on a laptop a lot easier (win!). What is also helpful is that you now get clear notifications when you fulfill an objective, and there are slow-fall and invisibility potions and frog eggs to add some fresh mechanics. 

Sadly and undeservingly, Looking Glass went bankrupt before they could finish the gold edition, but maybe this was for the better considering how little effort seems to have been invested in the Levels of the previous gold edition. Whatever the outcome would have been, it is unlikely that the world will ever know what the Necromancer’s castle, the college and the slum level would have looked like except for some crude drafts. After my review of Thief: Deadly Shadows, I will make a wish-list on what a legitimate Thief 4 (and not a s*dding reboot!) could look like. 

...and his equally crazy followers.

But regardless of what the future has in store for the series, Thief II: The Metal Age easily snatches the crown of stealth games, puts it smilingly on its head and rests among my most beloved games of all time.

Dienstag, 26. Juli 2016

Thief: The Dark Project (Gold) – The time is ripe for a bit of burglary.



Hell, yeah! This game is dear to my heart, and I'm about to tell you why. The Thief games, arguably, have changed my life, with the most obvious product of my lurking in the shadows being this blog. As a matter of fact, the original Thief games were so good that the newest part of the series, simply called Thief, comparatively, was such a huge letdown that I felt the need to raise my voice on the internet, resulting in this blog.

Garrett is not the best fighter, but if a guard finds him,
it's sometimes the only option left. Awkward!

The Thief games are a part of my gaming experience and part of the reason why I feel confident in talking about atmosphere, quality and what makes a game fun to play in the first place. Recently, I restarted Thief: The Dark Project (Gold Edition; Looking Glass Studios, 1999) to find out whether it still holds up to today’s standards or if it’s just not as gripping and interesting as it was when I was a teenager. And what can I say? It holds up, easily. But what makes the game so compelling apart from ob(li)vious nostalgia?
 
A Unique Setting

Thief: The Dark Project introduces Garrett, the sarcastic master thief who prefers minding his own business over anything else but somehow gets involved with a conflict prophesied by his patrons, the Keepers, a silent society remaining in the shadows of The City. The game combines fantasy with horror and steampunk elements, set in a predominantly medieval world – you will encounter sword wielding guards in mansions with fully operative alarm systems. Originally, Thief: The Dark Project was supposed to become a Cold War zombie-fighting game under a different name, then it turned into Dark Camelot, a fantasy game with a conspiracy story around King Arthur, a mad Merlin and a suspicious Holy Grail, but as the developers weren’t able to come up with an interesting combat system, The Dark Project was born. 

Now back to the (final) story. Ever since a long, long time ago, there has been a conflict between the Hammerites and the Pagans. The Hammerites are a mixture between protestants and freemasons and worship the Master Builder, a deity whom they believe to have gifted fire and craftsmanship to man. In contrast, the Pagans worship nature and the Trickster, whose design is inspired by the Greek God Pan. And, of course, there is the City Watch, the police. Each part of the Thief series sees one faction rise to power, which Garrett must prevent. In this first installment, Garrett deals with the Pagans’ ambitions to seize power not only over The City, but over the entire world (oftentimes synonymous in the Thief games). Unfortunate Garrett, driven by his greed and unaware of his actions’ consequences, causes most of the trouble he later has to fix himself and pays dearly for it. 

Angry Hammerites. Option 1: Run. Option 2: Die.

The game starts off with a tutorial and some cutscenes with standstill pictures, which sounds worse than it is, because these cutscenes are beautifully drawn. They are narrated by protagonist Garrett himself in a Film Noir-inspired style. After some introductory outlines, the player is dropped into the level.
 
Sneaking and Listening
 
As the game is a stealth game (in fact, one of the very first of its kind), the audio is a much-needed medium for Garrett (the player) to know when to strike and when to remain in the shadows (a light gem in the HUD (head-up display) helps the player to see how well he is concealed by the shadows). The sound of a lock picked, a crate dropping, a guard coughing, or just Garrett eating an apple – they all feel immediately real and are among the most characteristic sounds in video game history. 
 
The player gets to listen to guards chatting about fat lords stuffing their bellies, spectacular bear fights and other gossip. As soon as these dialogues are finished, the guards return to their duty of patrolling the corridors of their lord’s mansion, and Garrett, a weak combatant, can sneak up on them and hit them over the head with his blackjack and steal valuables nearby. As he does so, he should hide the body, because otherwise the comparatively smart AI (Artificial Intelligence) of other guards will be alarmed as they find the body. Furthermore, the player also has to avoid loud surfaces such as metallic surfaces and marble floors, as a noisy Garrett will rouse suspicion and guards will search for him. The player, however, has many devices to deal with any given situation, such as moss arrows (create a soft surface to sneak on), water arrows (to extinguish torches and create darkness), broadhead arrows (for a quick kill), flash bombs (to blind the enemy or kill the undead), healing potions, etc.

This zombie used to be a priest.

After a quick break-in into the Manor of Lord Bafford following the tutorial, Garrett decides to visit an old “friend” who owes him money but unfortunately is imprisoned in a (un-) dead mine. The choice of the developers here is interesting: After having a relatively easy level with human-only enemies (apart from two very small spiders), they decide to drop the player into a level featuring not only zombies (slow but hard to kill) but also Hammerites, who are very strong and fast opponents. Upon replaying I found the level quite hard for a beginner, because there also are quite a lot of (loud) metallic surfaces. So not only has the player to adapt to the zombie situation but also, when he meets the much faster Hammerites, the ground situation. 

Some people have stopped here, as either the zombies were deemed to creepy or the hammerites to difficult to beat. From an educational point of view, the Cragscleft Prison certainly is not the ideal second-to-beginner’s mission, nor is the Bonehoard, the level afterwards. However, it cannot be stressed enough: This game is not about walking in and shooting everyone in sight and being massively overpowered. It is about sneaking your way through, and unfortunately, it just happens to be a 90’s game with some maze-like level designs. It does not give you quest markers or detailed maps or lazy quick-time events. This game is challenging, and it is okay to get lost once in a while – you will find your way, eventually (and there is no shame in consulting playthroughs on Youtube).

The Bonehoard - Many an adventurer's grave. Source.

Environmental Storytelling Done Right
 
Each level tells its own stories. Take for example the Bonehoard: Garrett is, once again, in dire need of money. Thus, he decides to rob the tombs of the rich, but some other thieves have been there before. The player might expect to find only little loot as he goes through the first few tombs and suddenly finds himself in a tunnel network. Some tombs are isolated and protected by traps; the player gets an idea of the abandoned nature of this haunted place. In the course of his journey he learns from the fate of his less fortunate friends through diary entries and the objects he finds on the ground: Blankets, a pickaxe, and the occasional corpse. Some parts of the level were flooded, but the absurdly wide confines of the catacombs allow for multiple floors and dangerous heights as well. Every once in a while, the player is rewarded for his troubles with precious gems located in the warmly lit rooms in the vicinity of the level’s grand prize, the Horn of Quintus, which releases ghostly, melancholic tunes. 

This is how you tell a story through something as simple as a map. Source.

After that, it’s back to a not-so-nobleman’s mansion. In its missions, the game shows quite a good variety, a healthy mixture of archaeology-like Tomb Raider levels with traps, monsters and undead and break-ins into people’s castles which are, of course, not any short of terrible secrets either. Each of the sprawling levels offers generous amounts of loot and readables revealing the background story piece by piece. 
 
Another level that is worth mentioning is The Sword. No videogame in recent years has even come close to the amount of madness showcased in the compounds of Constantine’s private mansion, but the horror is much subtler than you might expect. In contrast to the marvellously creepy Haunted Cathedral, this place is less concerned with classical gothic horror, but instead relies on surreal effects and a perfect, unsettling soundtrack. It is one of the reasons why videogames should be considered a form of art. 

Not without Flaws
 
The levels of Thief: The Dark Project already work quite well on their own, and the Gold-Edition levels may add more to explore, but they are exhaustive in their size. The Thieves’ Guild is easily the worst level and some players argue that the game would be better off without its seemingly unending sewer tunnels. The Mage Towers, while interesting, are also of excessive size. The Opera House, in my opinion, is by far the best of the 3 additions, but overall, the Gold Edition's worth lies predominantly in fixes and improvements for the base game.
 
Over the years, not only the controversial Gold Edition, but The Dark Project itself has received lots of criticism. Many people pointed out that the developers should have made the game even “sneakier” and less like Tomb Raider, which I agree with to some extent. However, I would not go as far as to banish the horror levels from the game as some have suggested – as I explained, they have their very own right to exist and without its supernatural inhabitants, the Thief  universe would be incomplete. However, a thing that I could perfectly live without are Burricks. Burricks are man-sized lizards that in some cases cannot be avoided (although, as I recently found out, can be blackjacked!). They have way too many hitpoints and are silly and can be found in my least favorite level, The Lost City, which is a lava-fuelled mess.

Good luck surviving this place. Source.

A True Classic
 
Nevertheless, Thief: The Dark Project (Gold Edition) remains one of the best games of all time – for the following reasons: The gameplay is versatile (you can ambush people with mines, kill them with your sword, blackjack them and hide their bodies or ignore them altogether), the story is gripping (and shall not be spoiled any further!), the setting is sinister and mature, and the protagonist is most lovably sarcastic. Can you ask for more? You certainly can! – And my review of Thief II: The Metal Age shall follow soon. But for now, I will leave you with this treasure. Enjoy!

Dienstag, 19. Januar 2016

Why the Thief Reboot Sucks

The Thief-Reboot is getting a lot of criticism on the internet and elsewhere, and this article will explore the manifold reasons. The general issue is (spoiler alert!): Thief  is not in any way true to its remarkably entertaining and demanding predecessors. It clings to all the bad things AAA Gaming (that is, top-selling "blockbuster" games) stands for, most prominently mass compability at the cost of originality.

The first problem of the game is that its designers refused to let Garrett be Garrett - an antisocial, sarcastic, clever outlaw. Instead, they came up with the following: Our hero is kind-of selfish and anti-social, hence the motto "What's yours is mine", but then he gets a young, obnoxious teenage girl he has to care for and rescue - of course. Why not have the girl be the hero instead of damsel in distress? Because they were scared to alienate the hardcore fans. But you know what's alienating? Turning the protagonist into a generic shell with superpowers that we can level.

Thief (Reboot) will try anything to appeal to a large audience. Source.

Thief wants to be as interesting as Dishonored or Assassin's Creed, but lacks any depth. What we get instead is a game where we play a thief who may or may not go on a murderous rampage without any consequences at all. From the same school of thought, apparently, derives the idea that the player needs flashy quick time events where we run over rooftops and have to mindlessly press buttons and spend the rest of the time watching boring videos, the illusion of player control once again taken away. The game has so little confidence in itself that it would rather be a movie.
 
 Lots of Magic, but far from Magical

Storywise, Thief tries to make up for its misguided action gimmicks by rejecting the steampunk madness/silliness of its predecessors, but doubling down on the sinister tone does not work if you have nothing to offer apart from a generic story about magic that apparently can do everything that the plot demands. The antagonist oozes with clichés from Doctor Frankenstein to Joseph Goebbels, but he feels like a comic villain in his obsession with Garrett. The hammerites, pagans, keepers - anything that made the Thief series stand out - gone.

As if this was not enough, the game manages to fail even at its most basic aspects. The one thing I found most annoying was that Garrett cannot even grab a chandelier without having a fancy animation that takes up several seconds. In the original Thief games it was hard enough to steal something, you did not need to go through this tedious routine. But now, you have to endure slow-mo Garrett rifling through each drawer individually, grabbing anything shiny - if it has a reflection in the moonlight, it's worth a grab, even if it's a plain pair of scissors. 
 
As may be deduced from the previous, salt-induced paragraphs, I consider Thief a huge step backwards. Thief 1 and 2 were great; Thief 3 already had somewhat of an AAA smell to it; but Thief (Reboot) comes with the stench of a franchises' death. Thief tries to be everything and to appeal to everyone but ends up being nothing.

Further watching:
Zero Punctuation about Thi4f